Umar Vs Paul

Umar Vs Paul

Umar Ibn Al-Khattab and Saint Paul of Tarsis are two of the most revered figures in the world today. Though neither men are considered founders of a faith, they were both important in the establishment of their respective religions.

What is most significant about these two men, is that both of them were at one time enemies of the religion they later came to represent. And both, through amazing conversions, became adamant believers.

Who Was Umar Ibn Al-Khattab?

Today, Umar Al-Khattab is considered one of the most beloved Muslims to have ever lived, especially among Sunni Muslims. He is well known for his devotion to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), his domineering personality, strong faith, sense of justice, and excellent leadership.

During his ten year reign as Caliph, the Muslim empire grew from a struggling collection of tribes to the most powerful empire on earth. But he wasn’t always Muslim. In fact, at one point he was one of the most arduous persecutors of the early Muslims in Mecca.

Like most people from the Quraish tribe in Mecca, Umar was a merchant. And like most of them, he was also a polytheist and worshiped the many idols prevalent in Mecca at the time. He was known to be very intelligent and loyal.

When Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) brought the message of Islam, Umar was initially opposed to the new faith. He exhorted the other members of the Quraish to stop Muhammad.

He also participated in the Muslim’s persecution himself. One story relates how he beat a young Muslim girl so much, he did not stop until he had tired himself out.

At some point, Umar decided it was time to kill the Prophet to prevent the continuous spread of Islam and fracturing of Mecca’s society.

One day he took up his sword and went to find the Prophet and kill him. Along the way, he ran into his friend Nuaim Ibn Abdullah. Nuaim asked him where he was going, and Umar replied he was going to kill the Prophet.

Unknown to Umar, Nuaim was also Muslim. In order to protect the Prophet and buy some time, he told Umar to check his own family first as his sister and her husband had both converted to Islam.

Even more furious than before, Umar rushed to his sister’s house where he found her and her husband reading verses from the Quran. Upon seeing this, Umar began beating his brother-in-law. When his sister tried to intervene, he beat her too.

Umar hit her so hard she began to bleed, and seeing her blood finally calmed him down.

Despite the beating, his sister and brother-in-law refused to leave Islam. Ashamed of his behavior, Umar asked to see what they were reading. After they showed him how to make ablution, Umar read some verses of the chapter named “Ta Ha”. The words of the Quran touched Umar so much, he immediately decided to become Muslim.

After that, Umar was one of Prophet Muhammad’s (peace be upon him) most devoted followers. His daughter, Hafsa became one of the Prophet’s wives. And after the death of Abu Bakr, Umar was chosen as the second Caliph of Islam.

During his Caliphate, Umar orchestrated the conquest of the Persian Empire and conquered much of the Arabia Peninsula from the Romans. His Caliphate is also famous for the peaceful conquest of Jerusalem. Islam continued to grow, and by the time of his death, the Muslim empire encompassed Arabia, Persia, Egypt, and parts of modern day Turkey.

Who Was Paul Of Tarsis?

Saint Paul of Tarsis was born about 5 years after Jesus (peace be upon him) returned to Allah. Today, Paul is recognized as the most influential Christian to have ever lived. His writings make up a good portion of the New Testament.

Paul was also responsible for spreading Christianity beyond Jerusalem to many other parts of the Mediterranean. But he is perhaps most notable for bringing Christianity to the Gentiles, or non-Jews. Paul himself was born Jewish and was originally named Saul.

As a young man he studied Jewish law and became well-versed in Hebrew tradition. He was also a Pharisee, which was a very political segment of Jewish society. According to the New Testament, he was very serious about sticking to tradition.

In his early life, Paul used to persecute Jews that followed Jesus. He was on his way to Damascus to arrest some of these Christian-Jews when his conversion occurred. According to the New Testament Paul was struck by a flash of light and fell off his horse.

He then heard a voice coming from the sky saying: “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?”

Paul replied: “Who are you, my Lord?”

The voice replied: “I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting.”

When Paul stood, he was blind. His companions (there’s contradictory reports as to whether they also heard the voice) led him to Damascus where he was blinded for three days.

In Damascus, another person had a vision, this time a man named Ananias. Ananias was directed by the vision to baptize Paul and heal him of his blindness.

Umar As A Muslim

Umar’s influence upon Islam cannot be overstated. He participated in several battles alongside Prophet Muhammad including the Battle of Badr, the Battle of Uhud, the Battle of Khandaq, and the Battle of Mecca.

The Prophet would confer with Umar to get his opinion on important decisions. For example, after the Battle of Badr, the Muslim had captured several of the Quraish as prisoners of war. Prophet Muhammad asked both Umar and Abu Bakr their opinions on whether the prisoners should be killed or ransomed.

Umar suggested they be killed, but the Prophet decided to take Abu Bakr’s advice and ransom them instead. Later verses of the Quran were revealed showing that Umar’s opinion was the better one.

Umar was also very loyal to the Prophet.

An example of his loyalty is exemplified in the Treaty of Hudaybiyah. This was a treaty between the Muslims of Medina and the pagan Quraish. The details of the treaty seemed to lean in favor of the Quraish.

Being upset about the terms of the treaty, Umar approached the Prophet and asked him: “Are you not the Messenger of Allah?”

The Prophet replied: “I am.”

Umar then asked: “Are not our enemies polytheists?”

The Prophet replied: “They are.”

Then Umar asked: “Then why do we disgrace our faith (with this treaty)?”

The Prophet replied: “I am the Prophet of Allah and I will not violate His order.”

After that, Umar felt better about the treaty. And later he would admitted the Prophet was right when he saw how the treaty actually helped the spread of Islam.

There are also many stories of Umar as Caliph helping those who were suffering from poverty or injustice.

And as an administrator, Umar implemented many improvements including canals for irrigation, a record keeping system, a police force, a national treasury, and most importantly, the Islamic calendar.

Paul As A Christian

It should be noted, that prior to the ministry of Paul, the followers of Jesus were not called Christians. There were not even considered a separate religion. They considered themselves Jews who followed Jesus

Other Jews considered them heretics, but did not consider them members of a different faith.

Paul was more of a teacher than a leader. He wrote several letters, called “epistles”, to the different churches he met during his travels.

These weren’t churches in the traditional sense of the word; these were more like small groups of people who followed Jesus’ teachings.

Thirteen of these epistles are now part of the New Testament.

Since Paul never met Jesus, these epistles are more about faith than about Jesus. It is from these epistles that modern Christianity was formed.

Paul’s interpretation of Jesus’ teachings were vastly different from what was being taught by the “Jewish Christians” of the time.

Perhaps the most important difference is the relationship between Jesus and mankind. The Jewish Christians before Paul believed Jesus was the Messiah. However, Paul taught that Jesus was the Savior.

This was a very significant difference. A Messiah would:

  • Usher in a new era of peace and justice.
  • Restore the true Law of Moses.
  • Would rule over the world.

Alternatively, a Savior:

  • Is responsible for saving all of mankind from God’s wrath.
  • Is an essential part of belief.
  • Has died for the sins of mankind.

These radical teachings of Paul initiated the separation of Christianity from Judaism. Many of the Jewish members and leaders of the new church disagreed with his views.

However, since Paul’s version of Christianity was less threatening to the Roman Empire, and was preached to non-Jews, it eventually become the dominant view.

Comparison of Umar and Paul

If we compare their influence on their respective faiths, Paul has considerable more influence on Christianity than Umar did on Islam.

Here are the reasons why:

  • Umar is highly respected in Sunni Islam, but Shia’s tend to have a  negative view of him. Whereas, Paul is highly regarded throughout all of branches of Christianity.
  • Umar did not write any parts of the Quran whereas much of the New Testament came from Paul.
  • Umar did not deviate from the teachings of Prophet Muhammad, but Paul’s teachings were vastly different from what Jesus taught.

In terms of authenticity, however, Umar is considerably higher.

  • Umar was known to be a close companion of Prophet Muhammad, and was even related by marriage. Paul never met Jesus, and was born after Jesus left this world.
  • During his lifetime Umar was the unquestioned ruler of the Muslim world. However, Paul’s teachings were not accepted by many early followers of Jesus.
  • There are at many witnesses to Umar’s conversion. But there is no one to authenticate Paul’s vision and it is disputed if his companions even heard the voice.

In terms of global influence, it would be hard to choose one over the other.

  • Most Muslims know very little about Paul, and the same can be said about Christians and Umar.
  • Umar was a leader and warrior whose legislation effected millions during his lifetime. Paul’s following was large, but he was not a leader and some reports suggest he was executed by the Romans.
  • Outside of Christianity, there are not too many people who are named after Paul. But you will find many non-Muslims named Omar or Umar.

In conclusion, there is no doubt about Umar’s devotion to Islam and his ability as a leader. Paul seems to have been a very influential teacher, but he significantly changed the teachings of Jesus.

Hence, it is fair to say, that Umar continued the legacy of Prophet Muhammad whereas Paul initiated a new belief system and attributed it to Jesus.

Spread the word

10 Responses to Umar Vs Paul

  1. (le-havdil), A analysis (found here: (that is the only legitimate Netzarim)) of all extant source documents and archaeology using a rational and logical methodology proves that the historical Ribi Yehosuha ha-Mashiakh (the Messiah) from Nazareth and his talmidim (apprentice-students), called the Netzarim, taught and lived Torah all of their lives; and that Netzarim and Christianity were always antithetical.

    Judaism and Christianity have always been two antithetical religions.

    The mitzwot (directives or military-style orders) in Torah (claimed in Tan’’kh (the Jewish Bible) to be the instructions of the Creator), the core of the Judaism, are an indivisible whole. Rejecting any one constitutes rejecting of the whole… and the Church rejected many mitzwot, for example rejecting to observe the Shabat on the seventh day in the Jewish week. Examples are endless. Devarim (“Deuteronomy”) 13.1-6 explicitly precludes the Christian “NT”. Devarim 13:1-6 forbids the addition of mitzwot and subtraction of mitzwot from Torah.

    Ribi Yehoshuas talmidim Netzarim still observes Torah non-selectively to their utmost today and the research in the previous mentioned Netzarim-website implies that becoming one of Ribi Yehoshuas Netzarim-followers is the only way to follow him.

  2. Dear Omar Paul, i cannot argue w/ what you write here, but in islam to see is to believe,. it does not mean paul did not see JESUS personally thus he deviate from the teaching of JESUS. i respect your opinion, but try to read 1st and 2nd thessalonian of the bible if really paul deviate from the teaching of JESUS. i think your prophet mohammad who deviated the teaching of JESUS, coz your claiming that he is the last prophet, but i think not, maybe he is another pophet, coz, if he is the last prophet next to JESUS, he will preach what JESUS preaches, but he preach another topic in contradiction to JESUS preaching.

    • Thank you for your comment Maong.

      I don’t think you know much about Islam or the teachings of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). Because if you did, you would see that what he taught and what Jesus taught (peace be upon them both) you would see that there are many more similarities than differences. Therefore, we Muslims are actually following the teachings of Jesus (pbuh) more closely than Christians are!

      For instance Jesus and Muhammad (pbut) both taught:

      • Love your neighbor.
      • Worship the Creator alone.
      • Respect your parents.
      • Feed the needy, hungry, and poor.
      • Be truthful.
      • Do not harm others.
      • Do not steal.
      • Do not cheat.
      • Do not lie.
      • Be modest in your dress.
      • Be modest in your spending.
      • Forgive those who do you wrong.

      There’s a lot more, but I don’t have the time or space to go through them. There are a few differences in their teachings, true. But the core essentials of the belief between Prophet Muhammad and Prophet Jesus (pbut) are the same.

      However, the teachings of Paul deviated from the teachings of Jesus (pbuh) in the core essentials of belief! Primarily, that no one should be worshiped except God The Creator!

      Where does Jesus (pbuh) say: “Worship me. Pray to me. I am God”?

      He never says that!

      Where does Jesus (pbuh) say: “God is made up of three parts and I am one of those parts”?

      Nowhere does he say that!

      These are essential beliefs in modern Christianity that came from Paul but did not come from Jesus (pbuh). So in fact, Paul contradicts Jesus whereas Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) confirmed Jesus’ (pbuh) teachings.

      And the truth bears this out in the day to day behavior of modern Muslims. Most Muslim women today still cover their hair like Jesus’ mother (pbut) did. And modern Muslim men still wear their beards like Jesus himself did.

      However, most modern Christian women do not dress anything like Jesus’ mother, and most most modern Christian men do not wear beards.

      Muslims do not eat pork. Jesus did not eat pork.

      Muslims wash before they pray. Jesus washed before he prayed.

      Muslims pray by prostrating on the ground. Jesus did the same.

      Muslims raise their hands to call upon God. Jesus did the same.

      Muslims do not teach that God is a trinity. And neither did Jesus.

      Muslims do not worship Jesus. And Jesus did not worship himself.

  3. Paul was converted about 5 years after the Christ returned to Allah, around 35 CE. This fact seems to have morphed into the erroneous idea that he was born at that time. In fact he was “a young man” (Acts 7:58), and apparently already a prominent rabbi.

Leave a Reply